Boston United were beaten in the Lincs Senior Cup final on penalties.
Hosts Gainsborough Trinity lifted the trophy following a 2-2 draw.
Reece Thompson scored his first two goals for United, netting in the 41st and 86th minutes to cancel out efforts from Alex Simmons and Craig King.
The Blues prevailed 3-1 from the spot.
Gregg Smith netted for the Pilgrims with Ashley Hemmings, Thompson and James Clifton all denied.
Liam King, Ashley Worsfold and Curtis Bateson slotted home for Trinity, despite a Kern Miller miss.