Wyberton played out a 1-1 draw with fellow Lincolnshire League title chasers Skegness Town on Saturday.
Arron Scutt gave the Lilywhites a second-half lead.
However, Wyberton hit back through former Skegness United man Louis Saebe, who has recently linked up with the Causeway-based side.
The result leaves both teams 10 points behind league leaders Sleaford Town Reserves.
Gary Frost’s side host defending champions Hykeham Town in Lincs League action on Saturday (KO 3pm).